PART ONE:INTRODUCTION 3
CHAPTER ONE:A.THE SCHEME OF LIABILITY 3
1.The Warsaw Convention 3
1.1 Personal injury and death 3
1.2 Registered baggage 3
1.3 Unregistered baggage 4
1.4 Cargo 4
1.5 Delay to passengers,registered baggage and cargo 4
2.The Montreal Convention 4
2.1 Personal injury and death 4
2.2 Registered baggage 4
2.3 Unregistered baggage 5
2.4 Cargo 5
2.5 Delay to passengers,registered baggage and cargo 5
CHAPTER TWO:B.SCOPE AND APPLICATION OF THE CONVENTIONS 7
1.The Conventions and the Contract:the Conflict of Laws 7
2.Exclusivity 7
3.Beyond the Contract of Carriage 10
3.1 Carriage 10
3.2 Carriers 10
CHAPTER THREE:C.HISTORY:FROM WARSAW TO MONTREAL 13
1.The Warsaw "System" 13
1.1 Different limits on liability 14
2.Reasons for Reform 15
2.1 Harmonisation 15
2.2 Reallocation of risk 15
2.3 The interests of carriers 16
3.The Montreal Regime 17
3.1 Limits 17
3.2 Streamlining 18
CHAPTER FOUR:D.RULES OF INTERPRETATION 19
1.Broad Principles of General Acceptance 19
2.Article 31 of the Vienna Convention 19
3.Ordinary Meaning:in English and in French-and in Isolation 20
4.Ordinary Meaning in Context 21
5.Good Faith 22
6.Object and Purpose 23
7.The Object and Purpose of the Conventions on Carriage by Air 24
8.Supplementary Means of Interpretation 25
8.1 Preparatory work:legislative history 25
8.2 Subsequent practice 26
8.3 Commentaries 26
8.4 Case law 27
8.5 Other conventions 28
9.Consideration of the French Text 29
PART TWO THE CONVENTIONS AND COMMENTARY 33
WARSAW CONVENTION AS AMENDED AT THE HAGUE,1955 AND BY PROTOCOL NO.4 OF MONTREAL,1975 33
Article 1.1:Scope of Application:Carriage 33
Comment 34
Notes 34
1.International Carriage 34
2.The Persons Carried 35
3.Baggage 36
4.Cargo 36
5.Aircraft 37
6.Reward 37
7.Transport Undertaking 38
8.The Principle of Restitution 39
Article 1.2:Scope of Application:International Carriage 39
Comment 39
Notes 40
1.International 40
2.Carriage 41
3.The Agreement of the Parties 41
4.High Contracting Parties 41
5.Agreed Stopping Place 41
Article 1.3:Scope of Application:Successive Carriage 42
Comment 42
Notes 42
1.Carriage to be Performed by 42
2.Carrier 43
3.Undivided Carriage 43
4.The Parties 43
5.Carriage within the Territory of the same State 43
Article 2:Carriage Performed by the State and Carriage of Postal Items 44
Comment 45
Notes 45
1.Relationship with State Postal Administration 45
2.The Carriage of Postal Items 45
Article 3:The Passenger Ticket 46
Comment 47
Notes 47
1.Ticket 47
2.Delivery of the Ticket 49
3.The Indications Required 51
4.The Places of Destination and Departure 51
5.Stopping Places 51
6.The Hague Notice 52
7.Embarkation 53
Article 4:The Baggage Check 53
Comment 54
Notes 54
1.Registered Baggage 54
2.The Check 55
3.Stopping Places 58
4.The Notice 58
5.Prima Facie Evidence 58
6.Absence,Irregularity or Loss of the Check 58
Article 5:Documentation relating to Cargo 58
Comment 59
Note 59
1.The AWB 59
Article 6:Description of the Air Waybill 60
Comment 60
Notes 60
1.Making out the AWB 60
2.Three Original Parts 60
3.Signature 61
4.After the Cargo has been Accepted 61
5.The Consignor 61
Article 7:Documentation for Multiple Packages 61
Comment 62
Article 8:Contents of the Air Waybill or Cargo Receipt 62
Comment 62
Notes 63
1.The AWB contains 63
2.The Places of Departure and Destination 63
3.Agreement on Stopping Places 63
Article 9:Non-compliance with Documentary Requirements 64
Comment 64
Article 10:Responsibility for Particulars of Documentation 65
Comment 65
Notes 66
1.Statements relating to the Cargo 66
2.Damage 66
3.The Carrier's Liability to Third Parties 66
4.Causation 66
Article 11:Evidentiary Value of Documentation 66
Comment 66
Notes 68
1.Prima Facie Evidence 68
2.The Conditions Mentioned 68
3.Weight,Dimensions and Packing 69
4.Checking Cargo 69
5.Statements relating to Condition 69
6.Apparent Condition 70
Article 12:Right of Disposition of the Cargo 70
Comment 71
Notes 73
1.Subject to Obligations 73
2.A Person other than the Consignee 73
3.Prejudice to the Others 73
4.Other Consignors 74
5.Expenses Occasioned 74
6.Impossibility 74
Article 13:Delivery of Cargo 75
Comment 75
Notes 76
1.Except when Disposed of 76
2.The Consignee Entitled to Delivery 76
3.Charges Due 76
4.Conditions of Carriage to be Complied with 76
5.Arrival Late 76
6.The Rights which Flow from the Contract of Carriage 77
Article 14:Enforcement of the Rights of the Consignor and Consignee 77
Comment 77
Article 15:Relations of the Consignor and the Consignee or Mutual Relations of Third Parties 78
Comment 78
Article 16:Formalities of Customs Police or Other Public Authorities 79
Comment 79
Note 79
1.Fault 79
Article 17:Liability of the Carrier in the Event of Death or Wounding 80
Comment 80
Notes 81
1.The Carrier 81
2.Liability 81
3.The Damage Sustained 81
4.Bodily Injury 83
5.Accident 91
6.Causation 97
7.Embarking or Disembarking 98
Article 18:Damage to Baggage and Cargo 104
Comment 106
Notes 108
1.The Carrier is Liable 108
2.Damage Sustained 110
3.Destruction 111
4.Loss 111
5.Damage in Context:Physical Damage 111
6.Registered Baggage 112
7.Cargo:Defined? 112
8.The Occurrence 113
9.Causation 113
10.Carriage by Air qua Air Carrier 113
11.Inherent Defect 114
12.Inherent Vice 114
13.Defective Packing 115
14.Act of War 115
15.In the Charge of the Carrier 115
16.Performance Outside an Airport 117
17.Transhipment 119
Article 19:Delay 119
Comment 119
Notes 120
1.Damage Occasioned 120
2.Delay 121
3.Non-Arrival at Destination 124
Article 20:All Necessary Measures 124
Comment 125
Notes 125
1.Servants or Agents 125
2.All Necessary Measures 127
3.Delay 132
Excursus:the Concept of All Necessary Measures 132
1.Force Majeure 132
2.Reasonable Care 133
3.Utmost Care 135
Article 21:Contributory Negligence or other Wrongful Act or Omission 136
Comment 136
Notes 137
1.Contributory Negligence 137
2.Person Suffering Damage 138
3.Own Law:Lex Fori Applies 138
4.Exoneration 138
5.Other Wrongful Act or Omission 138
Article 22.1:Compensation in Case of Death or Injury of Passengers 139
Comment 139
Notes 140
1.The Carrier 140
2.The Monetary Limit 140
3.Special Contracts 141
4.The Form of Special Contracts 141
Article 22.2:Limits of Liability in Relation to Delay,Baggage or Cargo 142
Comment 143
Notes 143
1.Registered Baggage 143
2.The Sum that can be Awarded 143
3.Special Declarations 144
4.Actual Payment Unnecessary 144
5.Declared Sums 144
6.The Weight of Baggage or Cargo 145
7.The Package or Packages Concerned 146
8.The Weight of Parts 146
9.Affecting the Value of other Packages 146
10.Francs 147
Article 22.4:Expenses of Litigation 147
Comment 148
Article 22.5:Conversion of Monetary Limits 148
Comment 149
Article 23:Invalidity of Contractual Provisions 150
Comment 150
Notes 151
1.Any Provision Tending to relieve the Carrier of Liability 151
2.The Application of Exclusions 151
3.Inherent Defect,Quality or Vice 151
Article 24:Basis of Claims 152
Comment 153
Notes 153
1.Actions for Damages 153
2.Action Founded Outside WSC 154
Article 25:Damage done Intentionally or Recklessly 156
Comment 157
Notes 159
1.The Liability Affected 159
2.Intent to Cause Damage 159
3.Recklessness 159
4.Knowledge that Damage will Probably Result 160
5.Probable Results 167
6.Result 168
7.Scope of Employment 169
Article 25A:Servants,Agents and the Aggregation of Claims 170
Comment 170
Article 26:Notice of Complaints 171
Comment 171
Notes 173
1.Baggage Received 173
2.Cargo 173
3.Complaints in Writing 173
4.Prima Facie Evidence 174
5.The Damage Complained of 174
6.The Person Entitled to Take Delivery 177
7.The Carrier:the Person Authorised to Receive Complaints 177
8.Forthwith 178
9.Days from the Date 178
10.Disposal 178
11.Notice in Writing Separate 178
12.Dispatch of Notice 179
13.No Action Shall Lie 179
14.Fraud 179
Article 27:Death of the Person Liable 180
Comment 180
Article 28:Jurisdiction 180
Comment 181
Notes 185
1.Ordinary Residence 185
2.The Principal Place of Business 187
3.Where the Contract has been Made 187
4.Destination 189
5.The Principal and Permanent Residence of the Passenger 190
6.The Territory from which the Carrier Operates Services 191
Article 29:Limitation of Actions 191
Comment 191
Notes 192
1.Rights to Damages 192
2.Extinguished 192
3.Actions Affected 193
4.Brought in a Competent Court 193
5.The Date of Arrival 193
6.The Destination 194
7.Carriage Stops 194
8.The Method of Calculating the Period 194
Article 30:Successive Carriage 195
Comment 196
Notes 197
1.Carriage to be Performed 197
2.The Performing Carrier 197
3.The Accident or Delay Occurs 198
4.The First Carrier 198
5.Assumption of Liability 198
6.The Last Carrier 198
7.The Consignee and Consignore:Exclusive Rights of Suit? 198
Article 30A:Rights of Recourse 201
Comment 201
Article 31:Combined Carriage 201
Comment 202
Article 32:Mandatory Application 202
Comment 203
Article 33:Residual Freedom of Contract 203
Comment 204
Article 34:Extraordinary Circumstances 204
Comment 204
Article 35:The Definition of Days 204
APPENDICES 209
Appendix 1:The Montreal Convention,1999 209
Appendix 2:Authentic French Text of the Warsaw Convention,1929 225
Appendix 3:Guadalajara Supplementary Convention,1961 235
Appendix 4:Table of Correspondence 239
Index 241