PART ELEVEN. PROPERTY 1
CHAPTER 54. TANGIBLE PROPERTY 3
Ⅰ. Real Rights 3
1. Concept of Proprietary Rights 3
2. Objects of Real Rights 5
Ⅱ. The Statutist Doctrine 7
1. Lex Situs 7
2. Movables Follow the Person 8
(a) Theoretical basis 8
(b) Scope of the rule 9
(c) Exceptional function of the rule 13
(d) Obsolete remainders 14
3. Characterization of Movables and Immovables 15
(a) The traditional characterization 15
(b) The common-law rule 18
(c) The lex fori theory 26
Ⅲ. Lex Rei Sitae 30
1. The Rule 30
2. Property and Contract 34
Transfer of title 34
Transfer of movables 34
Lease of land 36
Conditional sales 39
Co-ownership 39
3. Right of Stoppage in Transitu 40
CHAPTER 55.SCOPE OF Lex Situs 43
Ⅰ. Creation of Real Rights by Transaction 43
1. Capacity to Dispose and Acquire 43
2. Form 46
(a) Exclusive lex situs 46
(b) The French-influenced group 47
(c) Irrespective of the contrast 48
3. Structure of the Right 49
4. Place 50
Foreign judgments 50
Ⅱ. Special Applications of Lex Situs 51
1. Remedies 51
2. Documents of Title 55
3. Easements 58
4. Encumbrances 60
(a) In general 60
(b) In particular 61
(c) Satisfaction 63
(d) Liens 64
5. Limitation of Actions 66
Ⅲ. Intangibles 66
Aggregates 69
CHAPTER 56. REMOVAL OF CHATTELS 70
Ⅰ. Principles 70
1. Successfully Completed Acts 70
Defenses 73
2. Defective Acts 75
3. Events in the Second Territory 76
4. Incomplete Legal Situations 78
Ⅱ. Local Public Policy 81
1. New York 81
2. France 83
Ⅲ. Security Interests 84
1. Normal Principles 86
2. Public Policy 88
3. Recording 89
4. Removal Without the Creditor's Consent 92
5. The Concept of the First Situs 94
American Legislation 95
Ⅳ. Adverse Possession 97
CHAPTER 57. AMBULATORY CHATTELS 100
Ⅰ. Goods in Transit 100
Ⅱ. Rights in Ships in General 102
1. Present Theories 102
River Boats 105
2. Situations 106
(a) The ship is in home waters 106
(b) The ship is on the high seas 106
Voluntary alienations 106
(c) The ship is in foreign waters 108
Involuntary assignments 108
Voluntary alienation 108
Voluntary securities 110
Other events 112
Conclusion 112
Ⅲ. Maritime Liens (Privileges by Law) 113
Anglo-American admiralty law 113
The Continental laws 114
1. Recognition of Foreign-Created Liens 115
(a) Repair and supply 115
(b) Wages of master and crew 117
(c) Injury 118
(d) Carrier's default 118
2. Priority 119
Ⅳ. Rights in Aircraft 122
1. Municipal Laws 122
Effect of Recording 123
2. Conflicts Rules 125
PART TWELVE.BILLS AND NOTES 127
CHAPTER 58.PRINCIPLES 129
Ⅰ. Sources 129
1. The Written Laws 130
(a) Communities 130
(b) Isolated laws 131
(c) Scope 132
2. Main Differences of Internal Law 132
3. Special and General Law 133
Terminology 134
Ⅱ. The Role of Theory 135
1. Municipal Theories 135
2. The Cambial Contracts 137
3. Influence of Underlying Relationships 139
4. Scope of the Cambial Rights 142
Cover 144
Enforcement Privileges 146
Ⅲ. Private Autonomy 147
Ⅳ. The Bill and the Accessory Obligations 149
1. Principles 149
(a) The principle of the basic bill 149
(b) The principle of independence 150
2. Difficulties 151
Examples of settled solutions 152
CHAPTER 59. FORMAL REQUIREMENTS 154
Ⅰ. Form and Substance 154
1. Essential Requirements 154
2. Narrow Enactments 155
Concept of Form 156
3. Scope of Form 157
Ⅱ. Locus Regit Actum 158
1. Imperative Function 158
2. Where is the act done? 159
(a) The Common-Law Doctrine 159
(b) The Civil-Law Doctrine 162
Locus verus or locus scriptus? 162
Delivery in municipal civil law 164
Rationale 165
3. Conclusions 166
Interpersonal law 168
Ⅲ. Exceptions to the Principle 169
1. British Law 169
2. Geneva Rules 169
(a) Article 3, paragraph 2 169
(b) Article 3, paragraph 3 170
CHAPTER 60. VALIDITY IN GENERAL 173
Ⅰ. Intrinsic Requirements 173
1. Capacity 173
Corporations 175
Exceptions 175
Conclusion 176
2. Consent 177
3. Consideration 177
4. Other Incidents 178
Ⅱ. Acceptance 179
Ⅲ. Special Contracts 180
1. Accommodation Paper 180
2. Aval 181
3. Acceptance for Honor 182
CHAPTER 61. CIRCULATION 183
Ⅰ. The Chain of Holders 183
1. The Effect of Possession:"legitimation" 183
2. Translative Function of Indorsement 184
3. The Doubtful Scope of the Principle of Independence 186
Ⅱ. Which Law of Indorsement Prevails in Determining the Rights of Holders? 187
1. Defenses of Warrantor 188
2. Spurious Signatures 190
Liability of Agent 195
Ⅲ. "Lex Loci Contractus" of the Single Obligation or Law of the Original Contract? 196
1. Negotiability 196
(a) In English and Continental Laws 196
(b) United States 198
(c) Conclusion 199
2. Indorsement After Maturity 199
Ⅳ. Single Law of Indorsement or Law of the Place of Payment? 200
1. Amount of Damages in Recourse 200
2. Defenses of Acceptor or Maker 201
CHAPTER 62. PAYMENT AND RECOURSE 202
Ⅰ. Payment 202
1. The Applicable Law 202
Place of payment named ("domiciled draft") 203
Absence of place of payment 203
2. The Scope of the Law of Payment 204
(a) Modalities of payment 204
(b) Time of maturity 204
(c) Part payment 205
(d) Amortization 205
(e) Excuses and discharge 205
3. Enlargements of Scope 206
Ⅱ. The Steps to Preserve Recourse 207
1. Survey of Theories 207
(a) Controversy 207
(b) Statutes 208
2. Necessity of Preserving Steps 209
3. Form and Time 212
(a) Form 212
What is "form?" 213
"Sufficiency of notice" 214
Renvoi 214
(b) Time 214
Reasonable time 215
4. Exemptions from the Duties 217
(a) Personal defenses 218
(b) Incidents of payment 219
(c) Estoppel 220
Ⅲ. Time for Suing 221
1. Suing for Recourse 221
2. Suing for Payment 223
CHAPTER 63. CHECKS 224
Ⅰ. The Special Law on Checks 224
Differentiation 224
United States 226
Function 227
Conflicts 227
Ⅱ. Creation 229
1. Form 229
2. Capacity of Drawer 229
3. Capacity of Drawee 230
Ⅲ. Cover and Stop Payment 232
1. Cover 232
2. Stop Payment 233
3. Restriction to Specific Holders 235
4. Time for Action 236
CHAPTER 64. CONCLUSIONS TO PART TWELVE 238
PART THIRTEEN. INHERITANCE 243
CHAPTER 65. PRESENT CONFLICTS RULES 245
Ⅰ. Terminology and Sources 245
1. Terminology 245
2. Sources 246
Treaties 247
Ⅱ. Survey of the Conflicts Systems 251
A. Plurality of Successions 251
1. Immovables under lex situs 251
(a) Movables under lex domicilii 251
(b) Movables under lex patriae 252
2. Other Functions of Lex Situs 253
(a) As principle for all assets 253
(b) As exception for all domestic assets 254
(c) As exception for certain movables 254
(d) For domestic immovables only 255
(e) Otherwise on the ground of public policy 255
(f) On the ground of comity 256
B. Unity of Succession 257
1. All assets subject to the law of the last domicil 257
2. All assets subject to the national law of the deceased at the time of his death 258
3. Mixed systems 260
C. Lex Fori 261
1. As principle 261
2. In Favor of Domestic Beneficiaries 261
(a) Reciprocity 262
(b) Prelevement 262
Contractual disposal 266
CHAPTER 66. PRINCIPLES 268
Ⅰ. Unity and Plurality of Succession 268
1. Historical Notes 268
2. Rationale 270
Ⅱ. Problems Concerning the Connecting Factors 273
1. Party Autonomy 273
2. Concept of Immovables 276
3. Renvoi 277
The Personal Law 279
Reference to Lex Situs 282
CHAPTER 67. THE FORM OF WILLS 287
Ⅰ. The Conflicts System 287
1. Basic Tests 289
2. Enlargements 291
(a) English legislation 291
(b) Typical civil law 292
(c) Interstate and international unification 295
Canadian Uniform Law 297
Hague Conferences 297
Scandinavian Convention 297
(d) Various rules 298
3. The Most Developed Reference Lists 299
(a) Texts 299
(b) Comparison:time of validity 301
Law of Place of Execution 302
Law Governing Succession 302
Law of the Enacting State 302
Domestic Wills 303
The Personal Law of Other States 303
Change of Personal Law 304
Proposal 305
Ⅱ. Restrictions 305
1. In Favor of Lex Causae 305
(a) French Code Civil, Article 999 306
(b) Netherlands Code, Article 992 307
(c) The Dutch Provision 309
Wills of Minors 310
2. In Favor of Lex Situs 311
Ⅲ. Operation of the Rules 311
1. The Concept of Form 311
2. Renvoi 312
3. Defective Formality 313
Ⅳ. Joint Wills 315
CHAPTER 68. SUBSTANTIVE REQUIREMENTS OF WILLS 319
Ⅰ. Testamentary Capacity 319
1. Law of Succession 319
2. Personal Law 321
3. Variety of Solutions 322
4. Vel instead of Et 322
Ⅱ. Other Substantive Requirements 322
Ⅲ. Restraint on Power of Disposal 324
1. Law of Succession Governs 324
2. Family Provision Acts 327
3. Restraint on Liberalities to Certain Persons 328
4. Gifts Impairing Legitimate Shares 330
5. Future Interests 331
CHAPTER 69. EFFECT OF WILLS 334
Ⅰ. Construction 334
1. Concept of Construction 334
2. Universal Principle 337
3. Conflict of Rules 340
4. Transposition 343
Ⅱ. Revocation 344
Formal Validity 345
(a) Law of Succession 346
(b) Effect Inter Vivos 346
Ⅲ. Election 349
Ⅳ. Powers of Appointment 351
CHAPTER 70. SCOPE OF THE LAW OF SUCCESSION 354
Ⅰ. In General 354
Ⅱ. Delimitation of the Scope 355
1. Status of Beneficiaries 355
(a) The incidental question 355
(b) Capacity of beneficiaries 358
(c) Rationale 360
(d) Public policy 364
(e) Unworthiness 365
(f) Corporations 365
2. Marital Property 365
3. Donatio mortis causa 366
(a) Act inter vivos 366
(b) Act affecting succession 369
4. Life Insurance 370
Ⅲ. The Right of the State to Take Estates 371
CHAPTER 71. ACQUISITION OF INHERITANCE RIGHTS 375
Ⅰ. Devolution 375
1. Principle 375
Conflicts rule 376
2. Transmission 378
(a) Title 378
(b) Possession (seisin) 379
(c) Specific legacy 382
3. Acceptance and Repudiation 382
Ⅱ. Agreements on Inheritance Rights 385
1. Release to Ancestor 385
2. Release of Expectancy in General 386
3. Promise of Testamentary Disposal 387
Ⅲ. Advancements (collatio bonorum) 389
Ⅳ. Partition 391
1. Coheirship 391
2. Partition 393
(a) Voluntary partition 393
Private partition; Waiver of partition 394
(b) Effect 395
CHAPTER 72. PLURALITY OF SUCCESSION 397
Ⅰ. The Problem 397
(a) Occurrence 397
(b) Scope 398
Ⅱ. Distribution 399
1. Intestate Rules 399
2. Requirements of Wills 400
Forced shares 400
Ⅲ. Acquisition 401
1. Option 401
2. Advancement 402
3. Prerogatives of Domestic Beneficiaries 403
4. Partition 404
Ⅳ. Administration 405
CHAPTER 73. ADMINISTRATORS AND COURTS 406
Ⅰ. Municipal Organization of Decedent's Estate 406
1. Common Law 406
(a) Jurisdiction 407
(b) Effect of probate within the forum 409
2. Civil Law 410
3. Situs 412
4. Law Governing Administration 414
Ⅱ. Extraterritorial Effect of Probate 416
1. Common Law Countries 416
(a) Assets in the forum 416
(b) Assets in other jurisdictions 417
England 417
United States 417
(c) Effect of ancillary probate 419
2. Recognition in Civil Law Countries 421
3. The German Certificate of Heirship 422
Ⅲ. Extraterritorial Powers of Fiduciaries 422
1. Extraterritorial Scope of Appointment 422
(a) Common law countries 422
(b) Civil law countries 424
2. Recognition of Foreign Fiduciaries 424
(a) Common law countries 424
(b) Civil law countries 426
CHAPTER 74. CLAIMS 429
Ⅰ. Single Law of Succession 429
1. The Question of Liability 429
2. Civil Law 431
Law of the debt 432
Enforcement 433
Lex situs 433
3. Common Law 434
Ⅱ. Several Laws of Succession 440
1. Lack of Privity 440
2. Equalization 441
PART FOURTEEN. TRUSTS 443
CHAPTER 75. TRUSTS 445
Ⅰ. Trusts in General 445
1. Municipal Systems 446
2. Categories in Conflicts Law 449
(a) Testamentary and inter vivos trusts 449
(b) Trusts of land and trusts of movables 450
(c) Creation and administration 450
(d) Voluntary and legally-implied trusts 451
3. Judicial Favor 452
4. Changes of Contact 453
Ⅱ. Testamentary Trusts 454
Rationale 456
Validity and administration 456
What rule? 458
Ⅲ. Trusts Inter Vivos 458
1. England 458
2. United States 459
Ⅳ. Conclusions 460
Ⅴ. Recognition of Foreign Trusts 464
1. Common Law Countries 464
English courts 464
American courts 464
2. Civil Law Countries 465
(a) In general 465
(b) Powers of trustee 466
(c) Inalienability of the fund 468
PART FIFTEEN. APPLICATION OF FOREIGN LAW 471
CHAPTER 76. ASCERTAINMENT OF FOREIGN LAW 473
Ⅰ. Judicial Notice of Foreign Law 473
1. Mere Party Evidence 473
(a) Foreign Law is a fact 473
(b) Like a fact 476
2. Discretionary Right of the Court to Investigate 478
3. Duty to Take Judicial Notice 480
4. Sources of Foreign Law 484
Ⅱ. Review on Appeal 485
1. Review of Conflicts Law 485
(a) No review 485
(b) Review of written conflicts law 486
(c) Violation of conflicts law 486
(d) Indirect review of foreign law 488
2. Review of Foreign Law 489
Ⅲ. Methods of Proof 490
Ⅳ. Absence of Proof 492
1. Rejection of the Claim 492
2. Presumptions of Similarity 493
3. Subsidiary Law 495
4. Distinction of Situations 497
(a) Acquiescence in the law of the forum 497
(b) Dismissal 498
(c) "Civilized Laws" 498
(d) Lex fori 499
PART SIXTEEN. INTERTEMPORAL RELATIONS 501
CHAPTER 77. TRANSITORY RELATIONS OF CONFLICTS LAW 503
Ⅰ. Change of Foreign Law 503
Change of the applicable substantive law 503
Change of foreign conflicts rules 504
Ⅱ. Change of the Conflicts Rule of the Forum 505
Occurrence 505
1. Court Decisions 506
2. Theories 509
(a) Applying the substantive intertemporal rules of the forum 509
(b) Distinguishing foreign cases 510
(c) Establishing general transitory rules 511
(d) Applying the new conflicts rules 511
Ⅲ. Rationale 513
TABLES 521
BIBLIOGRAPHY 523
TABLE OF STATUTES AND INTERNATIONAL CONVENTIONS 551
TABLE OF ANGLO-AMERICAN CASES 589
INDEX 611